Summary
Skepticism is a classic topic in philosophical inquiry. In contemporary analytic philosophy, scenarios like "brains in a vat" manipulated by supercomputers are often used as paradigmatic thought experiments to construct and debate skeptical arguments. Developments in modern technologies such as virtual reality provide a serious and tangible foundation for reflecting on these once science-fictional "brains in a vat" scenarios. This lecture will revisit classic philosophical analyses of the "brains in a vat" scenario, clarify the types and essence of skeptical problems, and evaluate proposed solutions (or deflationary therapies) such as semantic externalism and bit realism. The discussion will ultimately lead to philosophical reflections on the contentful-ness of virtual reality systems or artificial intelligence systems, thereby illustrating the intersection between classical philosophical issues and contemporary philosophy as conceptual engineering.
Guest Speaker:
Li Qilin, Tenured Associate Professor at the Department of Philosophy, Peking University; Deputy Director of the Institute of Foreign Philosophy, Peking University
Host:
Xue Shaohua, Associate Professor at the School of Humanities, Beijing Institute of Technology; Interdisciplinary Researcher in Philosophy and Cognitive Science at Renmin University of China
Discussant:
Fei Jun, Artist; Professor of Art + Technology Track at the School of Design, Central Academy of Fine Arts